If a German public works tender names or describes a product other than yours, a bidding contractor has two routes, each with its own conditions. Where the offered performance deviates from the technical specifications under § 7a EU (1) No. 1, the bidder can offer it within the main bid under § 13 EU (2) if it is equivalent to the required level of protection with regard to safety, health and fitness for use, and proves this with the bid. Or it can submit a variant bid (Nebenangebot), where variants are allowed. Above the EU thresholds, variants are only allowed where the contract notice says so. Below the thresholds, section 1 of the VOB/A applies where federal or state rules require it. Under section 1, variant bids are admissible unless the authority has declared that it does not allow them (§ 16 (1) No. 6). In both routes, the bidder submits the offer, and your job is to give the bidder what it needs to do this correctly.
This article is for sales and technical teams at building product manufacturers who supply contractors bidding on German public projects. It explains both routes, the formal rules that decide whether an offer counts, and how to support a bidder. It describes German public procurement law as at 11 November 2026 and is not legal advice. Private projects follow the construction contract, which is covered briefly at the end.
Two routes compared
Equivalent product in the main bid | Variant bid (Nebenangebot) | |
|---|---|---|
Legal basis above the thresholds | ||
Legal basis below the thresholds | ||
When it is open | Where the performance deviates from the technical specifications under § 7a EU (1) No. 1 and is equivalent to the required level of protection for safety, health and fitness for use | Above the thresholds, only if the notice allows variants. Below, where section 1 is required, unless the authority has declared that it does not allow them (§ 16 (1) No. 6) |
What must be shown | The deviation is clearly marked in the bid, and equivalence is proven with the bid | Above the thresholds, the authority's minimum requirements for variants are met |
Form | Part of the main bid | On a separate annex, clearly marked as a variant, with the number of variants stated where the authority asks |
The main bid itself must follow the tender documents. Under § 13 EU (1) No. 5, changes to the tender documents are not permitted. A bidder cannot simply replace a line in the bill of items with your product. It has to use one of the two routes.
Route 1: an equivalent product within the main bid
This route concerns a performance that deviates from the technical specifications under § 7a EU (1) No. 1 and is equivalent to the required level of protection for safety, health and fitness for use. The bidder offers it in the main bid, names the deviation clearly and proves equivalence with the bid. The rule requires the proof with the bid, so prepare it before the deadline.
What the bidder needs from you:
A comparison per tender item: each required property, the value in the tender, and your product's value.
The evidence for each value: declaration of performance, test reports, approvals, with dates and test standards.
Notes on installation if they differ from the specified product.
A named technical contact who can answer the bidder's questions during the tender period.
Focus the comparison on the requirements in the tender. A long data sheet does not help the authority decide whether the product is equivalent.
Route 2: a variant bid
A variant bid can offer a different technical solution, for example a different system build-up, as long as it meets the minimum requirements the authority has set. Above the thresholds, the authority must state in the contract notice whether it allows, requires or excludes variants. If the notice says nothing, they are not allowed (§ 8 EU (2) No. 3 VOB/A 2026, matching Article 45 of Directive 2014/24/EU). Where variants are allowed, the award criteria apply to main bids and variants alike, and price may be the only criterion.
Under § 16 EU VOB/A 2026, variants are excluded if they were not allowed, if they do not meet the minimum requirements, or if they are not submitted on a separate annex and clearly marked. These are formal points, and each one can end a variant before anyone reads it.
Support the bidder with a variant description written in the structure of the tender, a price, evidence against each minimum requirement, and a short explanation of what the variant changes for the building, measured against the award criteria in the tender documents.
Checks before your team starts work
Is the tender above or below the EU thresholds? This decides which rules apply.
What does the notice say about variant bids?
Which tender items does your product affect, and what do they require?
Can your product meet every requirement of those items, with evidence?
Which bidders are you supporting, and is the same information going to each of them?
Who in your team owns the questions during the tender period?
If the answer to question four is no, a variant is only worth preparing where variants are allowed and the minimum requirements still leave room for your solution.
Respect the tender and the planner's design
An alternative offer is legitimate when it meets the requirements that the building actually has. Keep your arguments to those requirements. Questions about the tender go through the channel set out in the tender documents. If the specification is product-neutral and your product meets it, the bidder can offer your product in the main bid as it stands. Read the tender carefully before you propose an alternative.
Private projects
On private projects without procurement obligations, these rules do not apply. Whether and how a contractor may offer another product depends on the construction contract, and approval sits with the client's architect or project manager, depending on the contract. Prepare the same evidence, because the questions are similar.
How Building Radar fits in
Building Radar tracks construction projects from early planning to tender. When a tender is published, Jeane, the intelligence inside Building Radar, summarises the tender documents. Whether the notice allows variant bids, and which items your product affects, is something your team still checks in the documents. See our tenders page.
Frequently asked questions
Can a manufacturer submit a variant bid itself? Only a bidder can. A manufacturer that does not carry out the works supports the bidding contractor. A manufacturer that also installs and bids for the work can submit its own bid.
Does a variant have to be cheaper? No. It is assessed with the award criteria set in the tender. Where price is the only criterion, the variant has to win on price.
Is an equivalent product the same as a variant bid? No. An offer under § 13 EU (2) is part of the main bid and concerns a deviation from the technical specifications with an equivalent level of protection. A variant is a separate offer, on its own annex, and only possible where variants are allowed.
What if the tender names a reference product with "or equivalent"? § 7 EU (2) sentence 2 requires such references to carry the words "oder gleichwertig". This article does not establish whether § 13 EU (2) applies in that case or how equivalence must then be proven. Clarify this with the bidder from the tender documents and have unclear cases checked legally. Our article on defending specifications in this series covers the same rule from the specified manufacturer's side.
Exclusive project sales insights, directly to your inbox
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Talk to us about public tenders
If you want to discuss how your team finds relevant public tenders early enough to support bidders, you can schedule an initial consultation.
:format(webp))